Listening to Laura Esserman is necessary for somebody
dedicated to taking care of patients:
How can we protect ourselves from the human errors
made by lack of judgment when analyzing data?
This is the daily work of most of us clinicians that help patients, reason
why we should get pay or not. Analyzing
data should be for everybody but most of us are already involved in the system
and we have difficulties to see what is best for patients. Or simply, we
become psychopaths when not looking at this data. Triathlon and sports (see the Olympics) are
full of coaches unable to see mediocrity or poor training. In Mexico people would say: “do not worry,
nobody is going to die.” Mexico is closing
the Olympics with no medals sending 126 athletes to compete. The cost of training for each one of the athletes
is as high as any developed country or perhaps higher. How the above is related
to the name of the post: triathlon and anemia?
I looked at the data of African nations regarding
hemoglobin (hg), hematocrit (htc) and related measures. It is the most efficient and economical way
of looking at nutrition and recovery in athletes. Anemia comes when nutrition and recovery are
not adequate for the physical activity done by the subject. The hg, htc and related measures suffer when
we are not meeting the nutritional and recovery requirements according to the
physical activity. How are the Ethiopians
and Kenyans meeting the requirements now when we see the African general
population suffering from low hemoglobin?
Bekele had a hematocrit of 49 when competing which locates
him above the 95th percentile of the African population; that
hematocrit does not come from African nutrition from what we know. Gebrsellasie has a hematocrit more in
accordance to African nutrition.
We
wrote an article related to the subject:
13 juin 2012
I read that Kenenisa Bekele has had a
hematocrit of 49, compared to the 42 of Haile Gebrselassie. We do
not have the conditions of how they took the blood sample to have a
better context in order to say something about it. In the same
article, they also mentioned that Bekele has 250 of Ferritin and Gebrselassie
150.
I have not
seen a Ferritin of 250 in natural conditions; a level that
high is only attained by IV iron. The majority of the Tour de France
cyclists carry values above 500 because we know that transfusions and regular
IV infusions take place. Our athletes have the blood taken first
thing in the morning during the recovery week.
Our ability to practice
triathlon will depend on the hemoglobin/hematocrit values one is carrying
according to the table below. Great
disadvantage takes place before even competing if our hemoglobin is below 15 for females or 16 for males.
The Africans have learned it well and now they make sure the
hemoglobin/hematocrit is as high as possible.
We now have the African doping scandal.
But going back to the title
of this post. We are afraid of calling
anemia when looking at the Hg values in Mexico and in Africa, but even changing
the name as Laura Esserman suggested for “idle” cancer. A treatment should be instituted if we want to
compete at our maximum capacity, but negligence is present in the whole process
as is the case of Mexico. Education is
the way but when it does not exist, doping becomes the only option to treat
anemia and related problems (lesions, chronic fatigue, etc.). Eufemiano Fuentes defended himself for the
doping of cyclists saying that “he was curing them with blood transfusion and
related substances.” We will continue educating athletes which is our main goal.
30 janv. 2013
I will paraphrase what Eufemiano Fuentes
mentioned during his interrogatory in court for the English speaking
readers. I copy from the newspaper Marca. There are
videos related to the interrogatory in the same newspaper.
Fuentes is questioning the way doping is
considered because he believes that he was treating anemia. It is
interesting because the dilution of blood when training is well known and could
mimic anemia. He mentioned that he was giving the amount of blood
needed to get to the normal level, always using the same subject’s blood. This
does not sound incorrect from the point of view of a medical doctor except for
the fact that the problem can be solved differently by administering the right
amount of nutrients at the right time; instead of the blood
itself. Fuentes says that time was the limiting factor; he needed to have
ready the competitor in a few days or perhaps weeks. But he knew
also that the administration of blood was doping for the UCI rules. Fuentes
questions that there is a hematocrit value of 50 as an upper limit; but there
is no low value accepted by the UCI to be treated. He took care of his
athletes because there is a danger in practicing cycling at a profesional level
with a low hematocrit.
Fuentes also
mentioned that who opened up the persecution by the police and the Operación
Puerto, Jesús Manzano, was using cocaine, and Fuentes did not want to follow
him up as a cyclist because of that reason.
Aucun commentaire:
Enregistrer un commentaire